There are lots of vitamins or multivitamins that target kids as there is a booming trend for them. You may come a cross some well-known brands, but there are also those new on the market that claim to be better. They all claim to be healthy and good for your kids, but are they?
Today, we are gona compare two brands of kids vitamins Hiya and Renzo’s, and see which option is better for your kids.
Final Verdict: Hiya vs Renzo’s
In the final verdict, when comparing Hiya and Renzo’s kids’ multivitamins, both brands exhibit a strong commitment to providing a healthy formula for children. They share several key attributes, such as the absence of added sugar, artificial colors, and sweeteners, as well as being free from major allergens. Both formulations include essential vitamins and minerals necessary for children’s health, with no significant differences in this aspect.
In terms of cost and purchasing options, both Hiya and Renzo’s offer the flexibility of both one-time purchases and subscription plans, with Hiya being slightly higher in price compared to Renzo’s.
It’s important to note that Hiya’s formulation simplifies dosing, as it only requires one chewable daily, regardless of the child’s age, whereas Renzo’s necessitates half or two tablets daily based on the child’s age.
However, taking into consideration all other factors, including better taste that children tend to love, Hiya emerges as the more favorable choice. Based on our assessment, we can highly recommend Hiya as an excellent option for parents looking to provide their children with a quality and appealing multivitamin supplement.
About Hiya and Renzo’s
When it comes to Hiya and Renzo’s, both brands offer chewable vitamins specifically designed for children. These vitamins prioritize crafting a formula that is not only safe and healthy for your kids but also enticingly tasty to ensure that children enjoy taking them.
Furthermore, both Hiya and Renzo’s demonstrate a commitment to safety and the origin of their kids’ vitamins by manufacturing them in the USA. In terms of manufacturing facilities, Hiya is produced in a cGMP-compliant and certified facility, while Renzo’s is manufactured in an NSF-certified facility. Both brands adhere to the highest standards in their manufacturing processes, guaranteeing the quality of their products.
However, when it comes to brand reputation and recognition, there is a slight distinction between them. Hiya’s kids’ vitamins have earned an excellent customer rating on Trustpilot, boasting a 4.5 out of 5 rating based on 724 reviews. In contrast, Renzo’s vitamins do not yet have any reviews or ratings, which may raise some curiosity. Nevertheless, it’s worth noting that Renzo’s multivitamin has received a commendable rating of 4.3 out of 5 on Amazon.
While both brands exhibit comparable quality and ratings, our subsequent discussion will delve into a more detailed analysis to determine which one offers a superior formulation for your children.
|Product||Editor’s choice Hiya||Garrnish|
|Where to buy||Official website||Official website|
|4.5 out of 5||n/a|
|Flavors||Taste like SweeTarts (according to users)||Green apple (new flavor) or Cherry|
|How appealing is the flavor||According to parents, kids adore the flavor and happily take the vitamins.||Some parents mentioned that their children refused to take the vitamins, while others stopped after just a few days. Renzo’s has released a new flavor which might offer a better taste for kids.|
|Vitamins and minerals||15 essential vitamins & minerals:|
Pantothenic Acid (B5)
|18 essential vitamins & minerals:|
Vitamins A, C, D3, E, K
B1, B2, B6
|Includes organic fruits and veggies||Organic apple, organic beet, organic broccoli, organic carrot, organic green cabbage, organic kale, organic parsley, organic spinach, organic blueberry, organic raspberry, organic strawberry, and organic tomato.||n/a|
|Suggested use||Recommended for ages 2 through mid-teens, taken once daily||n/a|
|Pork based gelatin||No||n/a|
|It can be used in the sink||Yes||n/a|
|Servings per container||30 tables (1 per day)||60 tables (1/2 or 2 per day)|
|Learn more||Hiya Review|
Kids Age and Daily Intake
When it comes to the appropriate age for administering both Hiya and Renzo’s vitamins, there’s a consensus in their recommendations:
Hiya: Hiya recommends starting at age 2 and continuing through the mid-teen years. They also emphasize that for children under 3, parental supervision is essential to ensure thorough chewing of the vitamins.
Renzo’s: Renzo’s follows a similar age guideline, suggesting these vitamins for children aged 2 and above.
However, there is a difference in the daily intake recommendations:
Hiya: Hiya’s multivitamin formula is designed to be taken once daily, simplifying the regimen for parents and children alike.
Renzo’s: Renzo’s, on the other hand, offers a different intake recommendation. For children aged 2 to 3 years, it’s recommended to take half (1/2) of a tablet daily. For children 4 years of age and older, the recommendation is to take 2 tablets daily.
This difference in daily intake recommendations explains why Hiya’s packaging typically contains 30 chewables, while Renzo’s provides 60. Parents should consider their child’s age and preferences when choosing between these two options, as well as the convenience of the recommended daily dosage.
Many kids’ vitamins may not immediately reveal that they contain significant amounts of sugar, with some packing up to 5g of sugar per serving. It’s essential to note that, according to Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital, the current recommended maximum daily sugar intake for children aged 2-18 is just 6 teaspoons or 25g. This relatively low limit can surprise parents, especially since most parents do not meticulously track their children’s sugar consumption, making it easy to exceed this daily allowance through snacks and sugary beverages.
However, when comparing both Hiya and Renzo’s vitamins, a significant advantage becomes evident: neither of them contains any added sugar or artificial sweeteners, which is indeed reassuring for parents.
Hiya opts for natural sweetness, utilizing monk fruit extract, and each vitamin also includes mannitol, a sweetener found in strawberries and pumpkins. Similarly, Renzo’s vitamins employ monk fruit extract as their sweetening agent. This shared commitment to zero added sugar and artificial sweeteners ensures that both vitamin options align with parents’ concerns about their children’s sugar intake.
Vitamin Formula Comparison
Let’s delve deeper into a side-by-side comparison of these two kids’ multivitamins, Hiya and Renzo’s, to better understand their compositions:
Hiya is thoughtfully formulated with 15 essential vitamins and minerals that play a crucial role in supporting the immunity, growth, and development of children. These essential ingredients include:
- Vitamin A
- Vitamin C
- Vitamin D
- Vitamin E
- Thiamin (B1)
- Folate (B9)
- Vitamin B12
- Biotin (B7)
- Pantothenic Acid (B5)
- Vitamin K
It’s noteworthy that Hiya’s multivitamin also incorporates a blend of organic fruits and vegetables into its formula. Additionally, it includes other ingredients such as natural sweeteners (mannitol and monk fruit extract), hydroxypropyl and microcrystalline cellulose, coconut oil powder, vegetable magnesium stearate, stearic acid, natural flavors, and natural colors (derived from beet root, turmeric, and spirulina), along with malic acid and organic rice extracts. The blend of organic fruits and vegetables encompasses a variety of nutritious options, including organic apple, beet, broccoli, carrot, green cabbage, kale, parsley, spinach, blueberry, raspberry, strawberry, and tomato.
Renzo’s, on the other hand, offers a formula consisting of 18 essential vitamins and minerals, including:
- Vitamins A, C, D3, E, K
- B1, B2, B6
- Pantothenic Acid
In terms of additional ingredients, Renzo’s includes mannitol, xylitol, natural flavors and colors, plant-based magnesium stearate, stearic acid, and monk fruit extract, along with malic acid.
Both multivitamin formulas share the distinction of being free from artificial flavors, sweeteners, and colors, which aligns with the preferences of parents seeking natural and healthy options for their children’s nutrition.
It’s worth noting that Hiya provides a more detailed and transparent breakdown of its ingredients, which can be a valuable point of consideration for discerning parents.
The taste of vitamins holds significant importance, especially for children. If a vitamin’s taste is unappealing or unpleasant, kids are less likely to want to take them. Often, children are drawn to vitamins with high sugar content and strong artificial flavors and colors, as they can resemble candy. It’s essential for parents to realize that just because kids enjoy a particular vitamin brand doesn’t automatically mean that these vitamins are good and healthy for their children.
As previously mentioned, both Hiya and Renzo’s vitamins are chewable, and when it comes to taste and flavors, some distinct differences emerge.
Hiya’s multivitamins have garnered praise for their taste, with kids showing a preference for them. One parent even commented that they taste like SweeTarts. Hiya’s chewables also offer a variety of colors and flavors, adding to their appeal.
Renzo’s, on the other hand, present a different picture. They come in only one flavor, with options like Lil’ Green Apple (a new addition) and Cherry Cherry Mo’ Charry. It’s worth noting that Renzo’s faced some challenges in the taste department, with a notable number of parents expressing dissatisfaction with the flavors. Some children refused to take them altogether, while others stopped after a few attempts. One parent even mentioned that their child had a negative physical reaction, nearly vomiting after taking the vitamin. This feedback might be why Renzo’s introduced the new Lil’ Green Apple flavor.
The primary goal of kids’ vitamins is to make them appealing enough for children to willingly take them. After examining parent reviews, it becomes evident that Renzo’s faced difficulties in achieving this goal.
Considering taste and children’s preferences, Hiya appears to be the better option, especially for picky eaters. It’s important to select a vitamin that not only provides essential nutrients but also ensures that children enjoy taking them.
Allergens and Gluten
Allergies are a serious concern, as they can significantly impact a child’s health. According to the CDC, in 2021, more than 1 in 4 U.S. children reported having some form of allergy. If your children are affected by allergies, you can rest assured that both Hiya and Renzo’s have taken measures to address these concerns.
Hiya is notably free of most major allergens, making it a safe choice for children with allergies. It does not contain:
- Crustacean shellfish
- Tree nuts (with the exception of coconut oil powder)
Furthermore, Hiya’s manufacturing facility is entirely peanut-free, providing an extra layer of reassurance for parents of children with peanut allergies.
Additionally formula is non-GMO, gluten-free, eco-friendly and vegan.
Renzo’s follows a similar path in catering to children with allergies. Their formula excludes:
- Shellfish (crustacean)
- Tree nuts (including walnut, pecan, and almond)
- Gluten (wheat, rye, barley)
- Milk (both Beta-lactoglobulin dairy and casein)
Renzo’s formula is also non-GMO and vegan.
Both Hiya and Renzo’s go the extra mile to ensure their products are safe for children with common allergies. This commitment allows parents to provide essential vitamins to their children without concerns about allergens.
Price Savings and Subscriptions
When it comes to the purchasing options and cost of both Hiya and Renzo’s vitamins, there are some key differences to consider:
Hiya: Hiya offers a 30-day supply for one child at a price of $30. What’s unique about Hiya is that when you make a purchase, you automatically start with a subscription that refills every 30 days. This subscription can be easily canceled if needed. Additionally, Hiya provides the convenience of ordering the right amount of vitamins based on the number of your children.
Renzo’s: Renzo’s Picky Eater Multi is priced at $25.99 on their official website. Unlike Hiya, Renzo’s allows you to choose between a one-time purchase and a subscription. Opting for the subscription offers a 15% discount, reducing the price to $22.09 per purchase.
Both brands offer competitive pricing when compared to other options in the market. The choice between a one-time purchase and a subscription depends on your preferences and whether you value the potential cost savings of a subscription plan.