Summary of Our Top Picks
Editor's pick
They take their digitizing process very seriously, and each item is hand-digitized by a team of technicians. They often offer discounts and valuable deals. You can send different types of media, including audio cassettes and reels.
Note: Pay in full or in 4 interest-free installments with Shop Pay.
runner up
As the name suggests they specialize in scanning photos, but they also do a great work of transfering videotapes and old films such 8mm and 16mm films.
Use coupon code ZOOPY45 for 45% off most scanning services!
If you find yourself in the quest for a digitizing service to preserve your cherished memories, specifically seeking an iMemories alternative, you've landed on the ideal platform. Several companies akin to iMemories not only match but surpass its offerings with a wider array of services tailored for diverse media types. One prominent contender in this sphere is Legacybox, standing out as a leading choice for media digitization. In the subsequent sections, we will delve into each alternative company, exploring their operational methods, and meticulously outline what sets them apart in comparison to iMemories. This comprehensive analysis aims to provide you with invaluable insights, aiding you in making an informed decision about the most suitable digitizing service for your precious memories.
Neither of these professional conversion services processes or transfers copyrighted material, such as Hollywood movies, shows, adult content, or any other content that contains illegal activities.
iMemories vs Competitors Comparison Table
Legacybox Editors Choice | iMemories | ScanMyPhotos | DigMyPics MemoryBox | Forever Studios | ScanCafe | |
 |  |  |  |  |  | |
Website Link | ||||||
Shipping kit (box) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
Free repairs (splicing) | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes |
Payment | Pay in full or in 4 interest-free installments with Shop Pay. | Full payment | Full payment | Full payment | Full payment | Full payment |
Average turnaround time | 10-12 weeks | 3-4 weeks | 4-8 weeks | 2-4 weeks | 2-3 weeks | 3-4 weeks |
Expedited turnaround time | 3-4 weeks | n/a | 2-4 weeks | n/a | n/a | 8-16 days |
 | 4.1 | 4.5 | n/a | n/a | n/a | 4.6 |
 | 3.5 | 4.7 | 2.3 | n/a | n/a | 2.5 |
 | n/a | 4.0 | 3.5 | n/a | 4.5 | 3.5 |
 | n/a | 4.4 | 3.5 | 4.1 | n/a | 3.4 |
n/a | n/a | 4.1 | 4.3 | 4.9 | n/a | |
WHAT FORMATS THEY CONVERT | ||||||
Video Conversion | VHS, VHS-C, Mini-DV, Hi8, Digital 8, MicroMV, Betamax, 8mm Video Cassette | Betamax, VHS, VHS-C, 8mm, Hi8, Digital 8, MiniDV, MicroMini, DVDs, MiniDVDs | VHS, mini VHS, VHS-C, Hi8 NTSC format tapes | VHS, VHS-C, Hi8, Video 8, Digital 8, MiniDV, Betamax | VHS, VHS-C, Hi-8, Mini Dv, Beta, Umatic, DVC Pro, DV CAM | VHS, VHS-C, Hi-8, Mini Dv, Beta, Umatic, DVC Pro, DV CAM |
Film Conversion | 16mm, 8mm, Super 8, Regular 8 | 8mm, Super 8, 16mm (with and without sound) | 8mm, 16mm, Super8 | 8mm, Super 8, 16mm | Super 8, 8mm, and 16mm | Super 8, 8mm, and 16mm |
Photo Conversion | Prints, 35mm Negatives, 35mm/126 slides | Photo prints (up to 12X16), slides (any size), negatives (any size) | Photos, slides including Kodak carousel slides and negatives | Prints, negatives, slides | Photo prints, Photos in albums, 35mm slides, and 35mm negatives | Photo prints, Photos in albums, 35mm slides, and 35mm negatives |
Audio Conversion | Reel to Reel, Audio Cassette, Micro-Cassette | n/a | n/a | Cassette tape, reel to reel tape | Reel to Reel, Audio Cassette, Micro-Cassette | Reel to Reel, Audio Cassette, Micro-Cassette |
PRICING | ||||||
Video Conversion Price | $59.99 for 2 tapes $279.99 for 10 tapes $559.99 for 20 tapes $1099.99 for 40 tapes | $14.99 per tape | $19.95 per tape | $65 - $600 | Standard Formats $11 per tape (or $16 per tape with enhanced quality) | Standard Formats $11 per tape (or $16 per tape with enhanced quality) |
Film Conversion Price | $59.99 for 2 films $279.99 for 10 films $559.99 for 20 films $1099.99 for 40 films | $14.99 per 50ft. | Starting at 19¢ per foot for 8mm, and 25¢ for 16mm | $65 - $600 | 3” reels $11 for 50 feet per reel | 3” reels $11 for 50 feet per reel |
Photo Conversion Price | $59.99 for 2 sets of 25 pictures $279.99 for 10 sets of 25 pictures $559.99 for 20 sets of 25 pictures $1099.99 for 40 sets of 25 pictures | $0.49 per photo, slide, negative | Starting at 13¢ per scan ($25 minimum) | $65 - $600 | $0.35 per photo, slide, negative or $0.45 with enhanced quality | $0.35 per photo, slide, negative or $0.45 with enhanced quality |
Audio Conversion Price | $59.99 for 2 audio items $279.99 for 10 audio items $559.99 for 20 audio items $1099.99 for 40 audio items | n/a | n/a | $65 - $600 | Audio cassettes & Microcassettes $17 | Audio cassettes & Microcassettes $17 |
Digitizing Companies: What You Need To Know?
When you're on the quest for a reliable digitizing service, ensuring you preserve your memories in a format compatible with modern devices is paramount. If you've chosen the path of professional work, high-quality results, and utmost safety, you're on the right track. Alternative companies competing with iMemories may adopt varied approaches to their operations, digitization techniques, and the resulting quality of conversion. One key differentiator lies in the methods they offer for sending or delivering your media. Some companies provide multiple options, such as utilizing a box kit, mailing your own box, delivering media in person to their facility, or arranging a convenient home pickup. It's crucial to assess which methods a company accepts, especially if this factor holds significance for you.
Concerned about the safety of mailing your media? Reassuringly, using the company's shipping box kit ensures your media's protection. These kits are designed to be crush-proof and are equipped with robust postal tracking capabilities, allowing you to monitor their journey every step of the way. Communication is key, and each company employs various methods to keep you informed about the progress of your media. Being aware of each step your media undergoes is a priority for these services, ensuring you are always in the loop.
Perhaps the most significant disparity between these services lies in the quality of conversion. While some services opt for a straightforward conversion, maintaining the media's original quality, others take an extra step. These advanced services might offer enhancements as an additional feature or include them for free in the process. These enhancements typically involve digital corrections that elevate the media's appearance beyond its original state. For many, this attention to detail transforms the preservation of memories into a true art form.
The final phase of the conversion process involves transferring the digitized media to storage. Virtually all services now provide diverse options, including DVDs, USB drives, digital downloads, and various cloud storage solutions. Concerned about parting with your originals? Worry not; all these services ensure the safe return of your original media alongside your chosen digital storage option, although certain services might levy a shipping fee for this convenience.
For those with time-sensitive projects, turnaround time is a crucial factor. This timeframe varies depending on the size of your order and the types of media being digitized. However, if time is of the essence, many companies offer expedited return options for an additional fee. This expedited service caters to those who require swift and efficient handling of their cherished memories, ensuring that deadlines are met without compromising on quality.
If you are wondering what each company accepts and converts from the media, please refer to our comprehensive comparison table below, which contains all the essential information.
1) Legacybox - Best For All Media
What we like
- Shipping kit provided for efficient process
- Regular deals and discounts available
- You can pay service in full or in 4 interest-free installments
- Accepts and transfers a wide range of analog media, including audio formats
- Customers receive email updates throughout the digitization process
What we don't like
- Some customers report a longer digitization process than expected
For those in search of a worthy iMemories competitor, Legacybox stands tall as a top contender, highly favored and frequently chosen by customers. With an impressive 4.1 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot, Legacybox has earned its reputation as a reliable and reputable company in the realm of media digitization.
Legacybox offers a comprehensive array of services, encompassing standard media types such as photos, slides, negatives, videotapes, and films. What sets them apart is their inclusion of audio media types like cassettes and reel-to-reel tapes, a feature appreciated by many seeking these services. If you're considering Legacybox, you'll find their approach streamlined and user-friendly.
The core of Legacybox's service lies in their specially designed box kits, available in various sizes: 2x Starter, 10x Family, 20x Closet, and 40x Trunk. These kits contain everything you need, and your task is simply to follow the provided guide, fill the box with your media, and drop it off at the nearest postal location. This hassle-free process ensures your media reaches them securely.
In terms of the conversion process, Legacybox maintains the authenticity of your media. They convert your content as it is, refraining from applying enhancements, edits, or repairs. This means you receive the original quality of your media, preserving its integrity and sentimental value.
When it comes to digital storage, Legacybox offers versatile options, including cloud storage, one-time downloads, thumb drives, and disc sets. This flexibility allows you to choose the storage method that best suits your preferences and needs.
Legacybox adopts a straightforward pricing structure, making it easy to understand. Currently priced at $15 per item, an "item" can be a tape, a film reel, an audio cassette, or, for photos, 25 individual photos, slides, or negatives. Additionally, Legacybox offers the convenience of payment flexibility, allowing you to pay in full or opt for 4 interest-free installments.
Patience is rewarded, with a turnaround time of approximately 10-12 weeks. For those in a hurry, Legacybox provides a 10-day priority digitization service for an additional charge. Upon completion of the process, you receive your original media back, meticulously preserved, alongside your chosen digital storage format.
To delve deeper into the Legacybox experience, consider reading our comprehensive review or visit their official website for further insights. Your cherished memories are in capable hands with Legacybox, where simplicity meets professionalism, ensuring your treasured moments endure for generations to come.
2) ScanMyPhotos - Best For Photos, Slides and Negatives
What we like
- Offers individual photos, videotapes and old film digitization and also conversion box options
- Ideal for photo scanning and photo restoration
- Easy online ordering process
- Positive customer reviews and ratings
What we don't like
- Return or disposal of original media may incur additional costs with transfer box option.
When seeking true expertise in the realm of scanning and digitizing photos, slides, and negatives, ScanMyPhotos is your ultimate destination. With a remarkable 33-year legacy in this field, this company has honed its craft to perfection. While you might not stumble upon an abundance of reviews, rest assured that ScanMyPhotos offers one of the finest services in the industry.
ScanMyPhotos specializes in the preservation of photos, making it their primary focus. However, their capabilities extend beyond mere photos to encompass media such as videotapes and old films. Operating primarily online, the process begins by creating an order. Depending on the size of your collection, you have two mailing options.
For smaller collections, you can opt for the pay-per-scan or individual VHS to DVD service. In this case, you mail your media in your own box. Conversely, for larger and older collections, the transfer box kit option is recommended. ScanMyPhotos provides you with the necessary kit, allowing you to fill it up with your media and then send it back to the service. This flexibility ensures that their services are tailored to meet your specific needs.
ScanMyPhotos distinguishes itself further by offering an array of additional features and add-on services. Notably, the "Photo Soap" option is particularly appealing. It represents the latest iteration of their computerized image correction process, enhancing the visual quality of your digitized photos. Additionally, for those seeking comprehensive image restoration, ScanMyPhotos provides a full photo restoration service priced at $45.50 per photo.
In terms of digital storage, you have a choice between cloud storage, digital downloads, DVDs, and thumb drives. This diverse range of options allows you to select the most suitable storage format for your preferences and requirements.
When it comes to turnaround time, ScanMyPhotos delivers efficiency, with expectations ranging from 2 to 4 weeks. The exact duration depends on the quantity and type of media you're entrusting to them.
Pricing is transparent, starting at $0.13 per photo scan, with videotape digitization commencing at $29.95 per tape, and film reel digitization beginning at $0.19 per foot. As for the return of your original media, please be aware that there may be a charge for its return or a disposal fee, particularly if you opt for the box kit service.
In conclusion, ScanMyPhotos shines as the go-to expert in digitizing photos, slides, and negatives. Their decades of experience, coupled with a range of services and add-ons, make them an excellent choice for those seeking to preserve their cherished visual memories.
3) DigMyPics MemoryBox: A Legacybox Equivalent
What we like
- Multiple service options and box kit sizes
- Detailed digitizing process with various storage options
- Ensures safety of originals
- High customer satisfaction
- Converts various formats
What we don't like
- Extra charge for additional items
- Relatively higher pricing
If you're in search of a service akin to Legacybox, DigMyPics MemoryBox stands as a close counterpart with a similar operational concept. Much like Legacybox, DigMyPics MemoryBox is one of the pioneers in the field of box kit services, simplifying the digitization process.
This service exclusively offers the option of mailing your media using their kit, emphasizing convenience and reliability. Their box kits are available in different sizes, ranging from the 4x Small, 10x Medium, 20x Large, to the 40x Extra Large kit. The 4-item Small kit is currently priced at $64 and includes all the essentials, complete with an instruction booklet. Much like Legacybox, you have the flexibility to add extra items to the kit and label them for additional charges.
Throughout the conversion process, DigMyPics MemoryBox ensures the preservation of your memories. They lightly dust photos and home videos and apply color correction to photos and movie films. These thoughtful touches enhance the overall quality and visual appeal of your digitized content.
For digital storage options, you have the choice of receiving a set of DVDs, a flash drive, and digital downloads, ensuring your memories are accessible through various mediums.
Turnaround time, as with all digitization services, is contingent on the size and type of media being processed. DigMyPics MemoryBox provides detailed estimates for their box kits, offering a transparent view of their projected completion times. These estimates include 12 business days for the Small kit, 15 days for the Medium kit, 18 days for the Large kit, and 20+ days for the Extra Large kit.
In conclusion, DigMyPics MemoryBox closely emulates the Legacybox experience, offering a straightforward and efficient approach to preserving your cherished memories. With their dedication to quality and attention to detail, your originals are in safe hands, ensuring they endure alongside your chosen digital storage options.
4) Forever Studios
What we like
- Converts all standard media types and also special ones such as audio tapes, reels, and CDs and DVDs.
- Highly commended by customers
- Offers repair for individual items at $7 each
- They offer personalized USBs with boxes (great for gifts)
What we don't like
- Pricing is higher compared to some alternative services
Amid the myriad of digitization services, Forever Studios is another good company that deserves greater recognition. With a presence in the field since the early 2000s, they have cultivated a reputation as one of the most innovative companies in the realm of media digitization.
What sets Forever Studios apart is their commitment to flexibility in how you send in your media. They offer multiple avenues for submission, ensuring convenience for all customers. You can opt for their Ship Kit, arrange for local pickup at available locations, or personally visit their center to drop off your media. This adaptable approach caters to a wide range of preferences.
In terms of the media they accept, Forever Studios goes beyond the standard fare of photos, videotapes, and old films. They also offer conversion services for audio cassettes, records, and reels. Moreover, they are equipped to handle digital media, including disks, memory cards, and USB drives. This expansive repertoire ensures they can accommodate a diverse array of media types.
Beyond media conversion, Forever Studios extends their services to include photo restoration and photo coloring. These additional offerings enable you to breathe new life into your cherished memories, enhancing their visual appeal.
When creating an order, Forever Studios offers customization options, exemplified by their approach to videotape conversion. You can choose between the original conversion (classic) priced at $9 per tape or the conversion with enhancements (gold) at $14 per tape. This flexibility ensures that you can tailor the service to meet your specific needs and budget.
For digital storage, you have a range of choices, including cloud storage, USB drives, or DVDs. This variety allows you to select the storage medium that aligns best with your preferences.
The entire order and processing journey is accompanied by tracking, enabling you to monitor its progress every step of the way. This transparency ensures peace of mind and a clear understanding of the status of your media.
When it comes to customer support, Forever Studios goes the extra mile. They offer a personal concierge service, allowing you to connect via call, email, chat, or even a Zoom call. This personalized assistance ensures that your questions are answered, and your concerns are addressed promptly.
Rest assured, your original media will be returned to you along with the digital storage of your choice. Additionally, Forever Studios boasts an impressive turnaround time, with expectations ranging from 1 to 3 weeks. The exact duration hinges on the size and type of media being processed.
5) ScanCafe
What we like
- Meticulous inspection, cleaning, and minor repair of films
- Frame-by-frame scanning at HD resolution
- Digital dust and scratch reduction for enhanced quality
- High customer satisfaction rating
- Competitive pricing and various digital storage options
What we don't like
- No provided shipping kit; you must use your own box for mailing
When it comes to photo scanning, ScanCafe emerges as a formidable competitor to iMemories, particularly renowned for its prowess in preserving photos and converting audio cassettes and reels. ScanCafe also extends its services to offer photo enhancements and photo preservation, catering to the meticulous needs of its customers.
Notably, ScanCafe adopts a slightly different approach in terms of shipping kits. Unlike some of the other companies on our list, ScanCafe primarily offers the ValueKit, designed for larger orders of photos, slides, and negatives. For smaller orders and other media types, you'll need to use your own box kit, following the instructions thoughtfully provided by the service. This may require a tad more effort on your part, but it allows for greater flexibility in the types of media you can digitize.
ScanCafe's expertise primarily centers around photo scanning, and their pricing for videotapes is slightly higher per tape in comparison to their competitors. However, their dedication to photo quality is unparalleled.
In addition to standard old media types, ScanCafe stands out by offering a unique service: data extraction from floppy disks, CDs, DVDs, and SD cards. They also accommodate special formats such as documents and large photos, stereo slides, and more, showcasing their versatility and commitment to preserving a wide range of memories.
For digital storage, ScanCafe provides a variety of options, including cloud storage, digital downloads, USB drives, and hard drives. When placing your order, you'll have the opportunity to opt for express processing and a faster turnaround time, although the cost of this feature increases with the size and type of your order. For standard turnaround times, you can typically expect a timeframe of 2 to 4 weeks, with the exact duration depending on the type and quantity of media you're entrusting to ScanCafe.
Rest assured, upon completion of your order, ScanCafe will return your original media to you, alongside your chosen digital storage option.
Abdo is a Zoopy writer who loves spending his free time outdoors, camping, and enjoying the peace that nature brings. He also enjoys fixing things - he's particularly good with electronics. His favorite movie is I Am Legend, and he's fascinated by survival gear and safety.