Preserving memories in this day and age means everything to us because it's what keeps us alive in a sense. Sometimes we can’t remember those memories because they happened a long time ago. You probably want to remember them, but they're unfortunately preserved on old outdated VHS tapes, movie films, or old photos.
With every passing day the technology advances, we start to lose the means to watch outdated media formats. Because of this problem I wanted to find a way to save all my memories to a new digital format which I can view on any device I want.
After analyzing and searching for the best company to digitize old media to the new and better modern format, we came across Legacybox and Costco. After further research into these services we found a third option by the name of iMemories which could possibly be even better than the other two. Stick around and see what we have to say.
We have decided to make an in-depth comparison guide, so you can easily decide which one suits you the best.
Name | iMemories Editors choice | Legacybox | Costco |
|---|---|---|---|
Product image |  |  |  |
Where to buy | Official website | Official website | Official website |
Videotape conversion | VHS, VHS-C, Betamax, 8mm, Hi8, Video8, Digital8, MiniDV, MicroMini | VHS, VHS-C, Hi8, Video 8, MiniDV, Betamax, MicroMV, PAL, Digital 8 | VHS, S-VHS, VHS-C, S-VHS-C, Betamax, Video8, Hi8, DV, DVCAM, MiniDV, DVC |
Film conversion | 8mm, Super 8, 16mm | 16mm, 8mm, Super 8, Regular 8 | 16mm, 8mm, Super 8, |
Photo conversion | Photo prints, slides, negatives | 35mm/126 slides, prints, 35mm negatives | Photos 2″ x 2″ up to 8″ x 12″. We cannot accept sheets or albums |
Audio conversion | No– | Reel to Reel, Micro-cassette, Audio cassette | No– |
DVD conversion | DVDs, MiniDVD | No– | DVDs |
Price | Videotapes = $11.99 per tape Movie films = $11.99 per 50ft. Photos = $0.47 per photo | 2 item starter = $59.98 (2 Tapes, or 2 Films, or 2 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 10 item starter = $279.98 (10 Tapes, or 10 Films, or 10 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 20 item starter = $559.98 (20 Tapes, or 20 Films, or 20 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 40 item starter = $1,099.98 (40 Tapes, or 40 Films, or 40 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) | Videotapes = $19.99 per tape Movie films = $19.99 per 150ft. Photos = $0.32 per photo |
Originals return | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Trustpilot score | |||
iOS and Android App | Yes | No– | No– |
Free image and video enhancement | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Easy edit and organize | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Shipping information | USA Only = Free Shipping Excluded territories: Micronesia, Guam, Marshall Islands, Northern Mariana Islands, Palau, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, Armed Forces Americas, Armed Forces Europe, Armed Forces Pacific | Contiguous USA Only = Free Return Shipping Excluded territories: Hawaii, Alaska, Puerto Rico, Canada, or anywhere else outside of the contiguous US | Contiguous USA Only = $5.99 |
Shipping time | 3 to 5 days | 3 to 6 days | 5 to 7 days |
How long does it take to digitize | 2 to 3 weeks | 6 to 8 weeks | 3 to 4 weeks |
Learn more | Read Full Review | Read Full Review | No– |
Name | iMemories |
|---|---|
Price | |
Product image |  |
Videotape conversion | Official website |
Videotape conversion | VHS, VHS-C, Betamax, 8mm, Hi8, Video8, Digital8, MiniDV, MicroMini |
Film conversion | 8mm, Super 8, 16mm |
Photo conversion | Photo prints, slides, negatives |
Audio conversion | No– |
DVD conversion | DVDs, MiniDVD |
Price | Videotapes = $11.99 per tape Movie films = $11.99 per 50ft. Photos = $0.47 per photo |
Originals return | Yes |
Trustpilot score | |
iOS and Android App | Yes |
Free image and video enhancement | Yes |
Easy edit and organize | Yes |
Shipping information | USA Only = Free Shipping Excluded territories: Micronesia, Guam, Marshall Islands, Northern Mariana Islands, Palau, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, Armed Forces Americas, Armed Forces Europe, Armed Forces Pacific |
Shipping time | 3 to 5 days |
How long does it take to digitize | 2 to 3 weeks |
Learn more | Read Full Review |
Name | Legacybox |
|---|---|
Price | |
Product image |  |
Where to buy | official website |
Videotape conversion | VHS, VHS-C, Hi8, Video 8, MiniDV, Betamax, MicroMV, PAL, Digital 8 |
Film conversion | 16mm, 8mm, Super 8, Regular 8 |
Photo conversion | 35mm/126 slides, prints, 35mm negatives |
Audio conversion | Reel to Reel, Micro-cassette, Audio cassette |
DVD conversion | No– |
Price | 2 item starter = $59.98 (2 Tapes, or 2 Films, or 2 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 10 item starter = $279.98 (10 Tapes, or 10 Films, or 10 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 20 item starter = $559.98 (20 Tapes, or 20 Films, or 20 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) 40 item starter = $1,099.98 (40 Tapes, or 40 Films, or 40 sets of 25 Pictures to Digital) |
Originals return | Yes |
Trustpilot score | |
iOS and Android App | Yes |
Free image and video enhancement | Yes |
Easy edit and organize | Yes |
Shipping information | Contiguous USA Only = Free Return Shipping Excluded territories: Hawaii, Alaska, Puerto Rico, Canada, or anywhere else outside of the contiguous US |
Shipping time | 3 to 6 days |
How long does it take to digitize | 6 to 8 weeks |
Learn more | READ FULL REVIEW |
Name | Costco |
|---|---|
Product image |  |
Where to buy | official website |
Videotape conversion | VHS, S-VHS, VHS-C, S-VHS-C, Betamax, Video8, Hi8, DV, DVCAM, MiniDV, DVC |
Film conversion | 16mm, 8mm, Super 8, |
Photo conversion | Photos 2″ x 2″ up to 8″ x 12″. We cannot accept sheets or albums |
Audio conversion | No– |
DVD conversion | DVDs |
Price | Videotapes = $19.99 per tape Movie films = $19.99 per 150ft. Photos = $0.32 per photo |
Originals return | Yes |
Trustpilot score | |
iOS and Android App | Yes |
Free image and video enhancement | Yes |
Easy edit and organize | Yes |
Shipping information | Contiguous USA Only = $5.99 |
Shipping time | 5 to 7 days |
How long does it take to digitize | 3 to 4 weeks |
Learn more | Read MORE |
If you're still not sure which service to choose, you can read our in-depth comparison articles:
What is Legacybox
The Legacy Box is a company that helps people digitize their memories. They can digitize many formats, from an audio file to video or photo slideshows, so you never lose your memories.
The company has 10+ years of experience and over 200 employees who will professionally digitize your VHS tapes.
How Does LegacyBox Work?
After you pay for the services, Legacybox will send a box in the mail so you can fill it with
your analog media. You can drop off any old content that needs converting and send it back to them. The shipping label comes prepaid, and they will keep track of every step along this process from the start until the finish. The process may take four to six weeks.
Advertisement
Continue reading below
What Are the Charges for Legacybox?
Digitizing media can be expensive. The lowest price is $60, and this covers two tapes or films, and 2 sets of 25 images. Other rates range from $280 for ten items and up to a staggering amount of one thousand dollars for 40 items.
What is Costco
At the Costco Photo Center, you can digitize your old VHS tapes and files through its professional services. The Costco company has a partnership with YesVideo, where actually YesVideo will transfer your memories, even if you order from Costco.
How Does Costco Work?
The first thing you have to do is to send your memories with a UPS prepaid label. Transfer time can vary, but approximately you will have to wait 3-4 weeks before receiving your digitized memories. You could also track any updates about this order online and verify its progress anytime you'd like.
What is iMemories
Some people have old movies that their parents bought years ago, but they can't play them anymore because of their age. Luckily, iMemories is one of the best companies to keep these memories safe.
iMemories is committed to giving you all the tools necessary for converting ancient relics into digital format. You can have your old media made on DVD or BluRay disc, depending on how precious these memories are for you. Apart from that, they also offer cloud storage for storing your newly digitized footage.
This feature gives users access to their memories from anywhere around the world! They even have an app available for iOS and Android so you can watch your old videos and photos with ease.
. Plus, with iMemories, you can decide who can view photos and videos in the Cloud.
How Does iMemories Work?
When you purchase their SafeShip Kit box you then fill it up with you old media and then ship it to them. They also provide free shipping via Fedex. The company will take a look at how much stuff you've sent and they will then provide an estimate of what it would cost to digitize your memories.
Once they receive your box of memories, the team of iMemories will digitize every item you have sent. You can then download memories onto a computer and choose whether or not you want to share your digitized memories with other family members or friends.
How much does imemories charge for conversion
The cost of sending tapes to the company will depend on what you plan to send.
iMemories is excellent value for money, with a high quality service at an affordable price. For the digitalization of a 50 ft. film or a50 ft. film or a videotape you will only pay $11.99 per item and per photo you will only pay $0.47. The iMemories is the cheapest solution between these three companies
Limited Time Offer! Save 20% on Digital Conversion Pricing with iMemories
Which Is Better, Costco or Legacybox?
Unlike Legacybox, Costco provides you with their own MemoryCloud online backup. You can share your memories on social platforms using Costco. Using Costco, you can create slideshows and enhance offline viewing. You can download the videos and photos to your devices and view them anytime.
Costco vs Legacybox
Both companies offer professional services. Costco offers their own free Cloud to store your memories, while for Legacybox you have to pay %5.99 for Cloud. Legacybox offers a better price, and more formats are accepted.
Advertisement
Continue reading below
Benefits of Legacybox
Legacybox works similarly as Costco. With Legacybox, you have to order a box and have it sent to you so you can fill it with your old media. It does not allow you to ship items yourself. Also, you must pay extra for digital download. Its main benefit is that you can track your package throughout the entire process.
Benefits of Costco
Costco can store your files on their Cloud for free for 90days. Costco offers a custom quote for every order, while Legacybox operates with flat prices.
What is Our Choice
Our choice for the best service to digitize your old photos and videos is iMemories. iMemories comes with an app that allows you to access and share your files from anywhere you are, while Costco and Legacybox don't.
Buyers prefer a company that can handle different video formats. iMemories can digitize almost any format.
The difference between iMemories and other content preservation companies is that it has a good reputation. Also, its services are both high-quality as well as highly recommended by customers who have used them before. iMemories offers more affordable prices.
With the continual development and increase in technology, gadgets, and gizmos, Amar never has a dull day researching new gadgets. Being an enthusiastic gamer, traveler, soccer lover, and avid car driver means that he always looks for the next cool thing to try out.
2 comments on “Legacybox vs. Costco Comparison Guide 2022”
Can you put 8mm and 16mm on CD's or DVD?
Yes, you can choose how you want to receive your newly digitized media. You can pick between a USB drive, Digital Download, DVD, or in some cases on Cloud Storage.